Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login

Because I made a few posts about how I don't like the name "Derpy."
Apparently Hasbro was pressuring WeLoveFine to remove or rename all merchandise with that character, and iTunes pulled the episode where she had a speaking role from their online store.

I've been accused of starting a petition that I've never even heard of in order to make this happen.

I'm very flattered, but bronies are giving me WAY too much credit for all this.  (If only I had that sort of power to manipulate a giant corporation like Hasbro.) I'm not the only, or even the most active person speaking up about the problematic elements with the character. I just happen to be a very high-profile fan who has mentioned it a few times.
Here are some posts by other folks explaining why it's an issue:
fromonesurvivortoanother.tumbl…
fromonesurvivortoanother.tumbl…
knightspendid.tumblr.com/post/…

The name recall is more likely more related to copyright issues than anything. Hasbro wants to own all their characters, but I bet they will have difficulty copywriting a slur like "derpy."

I find it a bit ironic that early on when I posted my opinion, I was accused of doing it for attention.  But now, 4chan is promoting the hell out of my deviantart page in an effort to direct flames at me:


This was unexpected, but I couldn't have asked for a better promotion. So, thank you.

And thank you to those speaking up for me and setting the record straight in the comments, I appreciate it. =)
Add a Comment:
 
:iconwiinick:
wiinick Featured By Owner Nov 24, 2014
Woooooooooooow. Just wow. Derp is a meme and has a few meanings. It doesnt always mean retarded, and it was being used in an endearing manner. She wasnt retarded, it was her eyes that got the name. It's people like you that are offended by everything that make the world a worse place because people LOVED this character, and you were a small part of why she-the character was changed, just so YOU wouldnt be offended. Selfish really. What's the matter with imperfection on TV. Why do they have to be perfect. Speech slurs, stuttering, and  crosseyed-ness should be on tv to get people to be more tolerant towards this. I have a stutter, I wish she stuttered or something like that, thad make her more relatable. Go get off your high horse and let the world be, get offended, well thats a personal problem nothing you should inflict on someone else. As an example, You may be atheist, your christian friends hear this, now they HAVE to get you to believe and they wont do anything with you unless you go to church with them to find this nonexistent god people like so much. To sum it up, you helped taking things too far. People loved this imperfect character. Good job in being a part in ruining that. You can argue against me but you got almost every brony on my side.
Reply
:iconzetriax:
Zetriax Featured By Owner Sep 14, 2014  Student General Artist
I hate people. Everyone's a retard online. I think you're cool man.
Reply
:iconfaggotry-raptor:
Faggotry-Raptor Featured By Owner Jul 6, 2014
Christ you're a real piece of shit. People like you are why tumblr Social Justice Warriors are ridiculed, because you latch onto crap like this and shit-stir for attention
Reply
:iconkomatsuzaki-xingqi:
Komatsuzaki-Xingqi Featured By Owner Jun 20, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I love all this butthurt in the comments. XD
Reply
:iconderroflcopter:
Derroflcopter Featured By Owner Aug 25, 2015
Oh hai.
Reply
:iconkomatsuzaki-xingqi:
Komatsuzaki-Xingqi Featured By Owner Aug 27, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
おはい。
Reply
:icontruucey:
Truucey Featured By Owner Nov 29, 2014  Hobbyist General Artist
Wherever opinions, ponies, or Gravity Falls exist, FlutterBOSS is sure to follow
Reply
:iconkomatsuzaki-xingqi:
Komatsuzaki-Xingqi Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
With his scurrilous method of discourse and unremitting wit, FlutterBOSS will come and turn the world upside down. He'll then remind you to take a freaking chill pill, because an upside Earth is still the same Earth, as things such as up and down don't exist in the galactic plane. Or something. 
Reply
:iconsteelcz:
SteelCZ Featured By Owner Jun 20, 2014  Hobbyist
2 years later and people are still making asses out of themselves? ...what?
Reply
:iconjonnando2000:
jonnando2000 Featured By Owner Feb 18, 2014  Student Artist
guys... everybody has their own opinion. Respecting someone's opinion doesn't necessarily mean you agree with it, but stop with the hating comments. You could be hurting her feelings...
Reply
:iconhelenaknowlegdeoffic:
HelenaKnowlegdeOffic Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2014
Love and tolerance my ass.
Reply
:iconwillibob10:
willibob10 Featured By Owner Jan 3, 2014  Hobbyist General Artist
derpy is an awesome name you f*King gumby
Reply
:iconthesnowballtv:
TheSnowballTV Featured By Owner Aug 25, 2014  Hobbyist Digital Artist
No, Derpy is a retarded name. Come at me, bronies.
Reply
:iconterthna:
Terthna Featured By Owner Dec 9, 2013
I disagree with you and your opinions, and wish you much misfortune and unhappiness in the future. I realize that it's petty, but seriously what gave you the right to be offended on my behalf as a mentally disabled person?

Yeah it's a little late, but better late then never.
Reply
:iconowlkisses:
owlkisses Featured By Owner Nov 30, 2014  Student General Artist
:thumbsdown:
Reply
:iconsegasister:
SEGASister Featured By Owner Nov 13, 2013  Hobbyist Writer
So...characters like Snips and Snails, Patrick, and Goofy get to stay, despite them being equally, if not more, offensive than she is? Or are girls not supposed to be retarded? Is that it?!
Reply
:iconwires365:
Wires365 Featured By Owner Sep 21, 2013  Hobbyist Digital Artist
What about Goofy from Disney cartoons? Are you against him being there too? Seeing as "Goofy" is just as offensive as "Derpy".
Reply
:iconbfwesh:
Bfwesh Featured By Owner Sep 8, 2013  Student General Artist
This.....is freaking pathetic. One of the many reasons why I don't watch MLP. (btw i just found out about this so yeah...)

I think Yamino is a great artist....but how an entire fandom can just hate on her over the death of a BACKGROUND character is beyond me.

And what's funny is that most of them are twenty year old men who really should be watching another cartoon (Don't rage on me insane bronies).

Seriously Yamino, don't let this get to you. Just ignore them.
Reply
:iconzetriax:
Zetriax Featured By Owner Sep 14, 2014  Student General Artist
I think Yamino's a guy. Just sayin'. But I agree.
Reply
:iconspeedyblupi:
Speedyblupi Featured By Owner Nov 14, 2014
His/Her gender is kind of ambiguous. Yamino is an androgyne.
Reply
:iconbfwesh:
Bfwesh Featured By Owner Sep 14, 2014  Student General Artist
Thanks. Oh and ignore the twenty year old men comment. I was an idiot for putting that and I realized that cartoons are for all ages to enjoy. 
Reply
:iconyumskittalz:
Yumskittalz Featured By Owner Aug 19, 2013
I understand your opinion, but I think Derpy was a great addition to the show.
Encouraging that it is okay to be different. My friend, who suffers from a 'mental' disability LOVES her. He thinks it's great that young children's shows are tackling that issue.
I also read the brony article you wrote on your tumblr, while I agree on some, I believe some phrases were exaggerated.
Reply
:iconyamino:
Yamino Featured By Owner Aug 21, 2013  Professional Digital Artist
The problem isn't that MLP shouldn't include a disabled character. The problem is including one whose name is a slur that means "retarded" and having her talk in a slurred voice and destroy everything accidentally.  That's not "tackling an issue."  That's making fun of a group of people who already have a lot of negative stereotypes thrust upon them.

What should happen is for a character to be introduced who has some kind of disability and not have it be a joke that encompasses their entire personality. But that's not what Derpy is.
Reply
:iconspeedyblupi:
Speedyblupi Featured By Owner Nov 14, 2014
Derpy does NOT mean retarded, and no-one ever thought it did until some idiots went looking for stuff to get offended by.
Reply
:iconlassmichnicht:
Lassmichnicht Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2014  Student Writer
I'll respect your opinion, but, why? So children won't know that disabled individuals are people too? It gives an actual human-like perception to the show. It shows everyone is different in their own way. And "derp" does not mean retarded, it means silly or goofy. It was a trend on the Internet.
Reply
:iconredpanda23:
RedPanda23 Featured By Owner Sep 2, 2013
Oh my god.You idiot.You're reading way too deep into this.It's like saying Clumsy Smurf shouldn't be in the Smurfs.And Derpy doesn't mean retarded,it just means...derp.
Reply
:iconbfwesh:
Bfwesh Featured By Owner Sep 8, 2013  Student General Artist
In my opinion it's the majority of the brony fandom who are idiots.

So she made a mistake and killed off a character, well the logical thing would be to accept that it's a mistake

NO LETS SEND OFFENSIVE MESSAGES AND RAGE ON HER JOURNALS.

*facepalm* stupid bronies. (no offense to any "sane" brony fans btw.) I swear, fans sometimes are freaking idiots.

Even if i don't watch MLP it's still EXTREMELY stupid to throw a tantrum over it and any show in general (except Nick Studio 10). I mean....really?

But just to reassure you, you guys are not the worst fandom. The majority of you are crazy but no, you are not the worst fandom. Just look at football....
Reply
:iconkello2702:
Kello2702 Featured By Owner Aug 6, 2014
I totally agree with you. Im a brony myself, and this is just fucking stupid. So a background character is pulled out of the show. Big whoop. But no, bronies need to go and send treats involving ending his life. I sometimes hate to be a part of this fandom 
Reply
:iconbfwesh:
Bfwesh Featured By Owner Aug 7, 2014  Student General Artist
Follow what you like. Just don't give in to what I'd like to call "Fandom Mentality".
Reply
:iconstavekoff:
Stavekoff Featured By Owner Jul 12, 2013
Yeah, I kinda feel like a poop after meeting you. You're really awesome, I'm really digging Sister Claire a whole heck of a lot.
Reply
:icondarrencross:
DarrenCross Featured By Owner Jun 21, 2013
I am, and always have been on Yamino's side. And anyone willing to subtract even one fucking second of their day in order to spend time bashing her for shit they're not even entirely certain she did is just another worthless brony who's let their rose-tinted glasses not allow them to see the problems with the things they claim they adhere to and love. This is why I don't choose to pertain to the label "brony". It's fucking filthy.
Reply
:iconbrendel-lytton:
Brendel-Lytton Featured By Owner Apr 27, 2013
I've read all of the links describing why this SHOULD be offensive, and you know what? I'm not seeing it. Should we be offended simply by the portrayal of a mentally/physically handicapped pony in a children's cartoon? If so, why?

I've read that others find this offensive, and so I should respect their opinion... but that's not my way. I respect that you HAVE and ARE ENTITLED TO an opinion, but if you can't provide a substantive line of reasoning supporting it, then I'm certainly not going to respect it.

That a pony is portrayed as mentally/physically handicapped pony is not offensive. To BE offended by such is, ironically enough, offensive... at least, to me. Handicapped people are among us, living and interacting socially with everyone else, just like everyone else. Rainbow Dash treated her as incapable? Is this not the perfect opportunity to include a scenario just like this, that any kid watching the show might find themselves involved with in the real world, and then demonstrate how such people might overcome their initial reactions and treat others with the same respect they expect? Or should we just sweep them under the rug, and not acknowledge their existence at all?

That the pony is named Derpy is also not offensive, or at the very least it is no more offensive than, say, Ditzy. Of course, some people could find it offensive... but then, some people could find Pinkie Pie offensive. Why? Because the same deviant social group that uses derp as an insulting term also interpret Pinkie Pie's name as 'vagina'. So yeah, let's get rid of her too, because you know that reprobates are out there doing this, and removing her from the show is the surest way to prevent this from happening... oh, wait.

So yeah... if this is the best that you can manage, then I would say that the anger is justified, even if some of the responses are not. Why don't you spend some time being offended by some of the truly offensive stereotypical depictions of the main ponies in the series?
Reply
:iconnyerguds:
Nyerguds Featured By Owner Aug 1, 2013

Not to mention, they had a psychiatric case with a screw as cutie mark, too, implying the pony was "screwy" or had a "screw loose". The community immediately picked up on that and gave it the strongly implied name. Was that offensive towards real life psychiatric cases? I think not. It's a cartoon, and people laugh at such things. Because they're funny.


I feel sorry for people who can't laugh at such things. In the end, ALL humour makes fun of something.

Reply
:iconsnap-draggon:
Snap-Draggon Featured By Owner Feb 16, 2013  Hobbyist Artist
I doubt you'll read this, but what the hell.
"A simple, undefined reply when an ignorant comment or action is made. Brought to life in the South Park series, when Mr. Derp made a guest apperance at South Park Elementary as the chef for a day, followed by hitting himself in the head with a hammer and exclaiming "Derp!""
The Term Derp does not mean (And I can't believe I'm saying this)[Le Triggerwarning XXDDDDD] Retarded, Mentally Defunct, Or stupid. It is an exclamation of silliness, and the fact that someone can get exasperated over the fact that a Character from a cartoon for little girls has a name 'Derpy' (A name lovingly given to her by the fans of the show as a term of endearment due to her crossed eyes from an animation error). Also, crossed eyes does not equate to retardation; I'd ask you to educate yourself as to what 'Brown's Syndrome' is(Start here: [link]), but I know that you are beyond accepting this; as it challenges your anti-abliest belief system. And 4chan is not promoting your page to direct flamers at you, that is ridiculous. The internet is an open medium and people are going to find your deviant-art page; Especially when you do something stupid.
Reply
:iconspasticartist:
spasticArtist Featured By Owner Apr 14, 2013  Professional General Artist
FUCKING THIS. Yamino, I highly respect you as an artist, especially since you like all the same fandoms I do, but you (and everyone else offended with Derpy) should figure out the flavor before sipping the Kool Aid. I respect the fact that you have an opinion, and am not angered that it is different than my own, the only reason I am angry is because you and the other offended people made "derp" into a slur for retarded people when it's not. My little brother has ADHD, and I know that doesn't really count, but he was disappointed when her voice was changed, to the point of crying. (not to guilt trip you or anything, but it needed saying.) There's negative reactions on both sides.
Reply
:iconafraidtodraw:
AfraidToDraw Featured By Owner Feb 1, 2013
Your numbers are going up but your fans are going down. Your now famous for fucking up 2 shows for your own selfish ends, how do you think a new fandom will react to you when they see you joining?

You got to exercise a little bit of cliquey power and attention whore like a lonely 16 year old, but in the end was it really worth it for anyone?
Reply
:icondinomar-de-contis:
Dinomar-de-Contis Featured By Owner Feb 5, 2013  Student Filmographer
"your"...
Bravo... Bravo...
And, generally, i hope you are joking
Reply
:iconnemo-tv-champion:
Nemo-TV-Champion Featured By Owner Feb 3, 2013  Student General Artist
2 shows?? if I may ask what was the other show (this is news to me)?
Reply
:iconkrawczyk:
Krawczyk Featured By Owner May 19, 2014
They're referring to the Adventure Time thing. Currently if you type 'yamino' into google the fifth or so result is 'yamino adventure time fired' though I don't follow that show at all so I don't know what that's about, just didn't interest me.
Reply
:iconspasticartist:
spasticArtist Featured By Owner Apr 19, 2013  Professional General Artist
IDK, but I would like to know too.
Reply
:iconimmblueversion:
immblueversion Featured By Owner Jan 21, 2013
Having only become a brony after the "Derpygate" incident, it is my understanding your only "crime" (or so to speak) in the matter is expressing concern about how people CAN interpret the name "Derpy" in a negative light. While I do understand such an interpretation, I do not agree with it. But neither do I agree with the idea that CHOOSING to interpret the name as an endearing character trait, which I know you know a number of fans (including myself) practice, gives one the right to act condescending and, for lack of a better word, cruel to others for having different thoughts.

I would like to think that if I were a brony by the time "Derpygate" were in full swing, I would have reacted in a more civilized manner than others. But I realize such hopes are of folly. And so, I will simply remain fond of the show and all its fans with the decency to act out of kindness and understanding rather than cruelty and ignorance. For the latter, I will not tolerate them. Because quite frankly, if both the show and your experiences have taught me anything, it's that are times when one must face people who don't DESERVE to be tolerated.
Reply
:iconbogeycroatia:
BogeyCroatia Featured By Owner Jan 13, 2013  Student Digital Artist
aw, I feel so bad for you!
Nobody deserves to be hated this much. :(
But I see what you mean about the character. And I don't get why people are this angry. Hasbro changed the name and fixed the eyes, and that's that.
Reply
:icontemporarythisthat:
TemporaryThisThat Featured By Owner Jan 16, 2013
No, that's not that. First off all, thanks for saying "fixed her eyes". I'm just going to fix my eyes noOOH wait I can't!

Secondly, she has been removed from the show completely, and she was removed ever since in February when this went down. This was all caused by about 10 people sending letters to one of the writers of the show, saying she's an ableist (despite her having a son with disabilities). Yes, the person who wrote Derpy into the episode had a disabled son.

The hate is really somewhat understandable when you consider how many persons, disabled and not, who loved Derpy Hooves and who are now really upset that she is gone from the show forever because a small group of people thought they should dictate what others should find offensive.
Reply
:iconbogeycroatia:
BogeyCroatia Featured By Owner Jan 16, 2013  Student Digital Artist
By "fixed her eyes" I meant that they would change her eyes and make them straight instead of "derped".

Secondly, I thought they just changed her by eyes and voice actor. I haven't seen the episode after they sent letters to the writers of the show.

I can see that a lot of people loved Derpy Hooves were angry and upset, and I'm not saying they can't be mad, because they have the complete right to. But it's mean and unnecessary to be as mad as some people are about Yamino. Some people are threatening her life and telling her to "burn in hell" because she wanted Derpy changed. If you listen to "what went wrong" by YAC you'll see what I mean
Reply
:icontemporarythisthat:
TemporaryThisThat Featured By Owner Jan 16, 2013
The episodes animated after the letters were sent were (short from one vague exception) are completely devoid of Derpy. As a person with lazy eyes I'm very upset that people managed to remove one of the few cross eyed characters on television.

I think part of the reason why people are mad at Yamino is the way she insulted all Derpy fans by saying stuff like "this is the type of fans you're pandering to" and sending Amy Keating comments from angry 4channers, basically claiming that all Derpy fans are trolls. Part could also be the way she deleted perfectly valid comments from people with disabilities who disagreed with her, while leaving very rude comments calling bronies retards (hey, I thought that was ableist) and comments like you said say "burn in hell". People see what they are told to see.
Reply
:iconbogeycroatia:
BogeyCroatia Featured By Owner Jan 17, 2013  Student Digital Artist
I understand, I can see why the bronies were so mad and such
Reply
:iconday-ton:
DAY-TON Featured By Owner Jan 4, 2013
the term "Derpy" does not directly relate to being in any way shape or form "retarded" or to have any mental issue. but leans more towards laziness or absent mindedness
Reply
:iconroseweave:
Roseweave Featured By Owner Dec 24, 2012
I don't agree with you with regards this, but you're not precisely doing morally wrong either. These bronies on the other hand...

People still keep mentioning you on /co/.
Reply
Hidden by Owner
Add a Comment:
 
×

Featured in Collections

Journals by Chidi-The-Litleo


More from DeviantArt



Details

Submitted on
February 3, 2012
Link
Thumb

Stats

Views
27,838
Favourites
26 (who?)
Comments
1,169
×